good choices.
both the xarcade and streetfighter anniversary edition got mediocre reviews but that doesn't mean they won't fit your arcade fighting bill.
Not too long ago, we had a celebrity player from the states wtfpwn ALL competition on the island using the street fighter anniversary stick. I mean total and utter domination of the competition.
So even though the reviews say it isn't perfect, the stick can do the job.
Personally, I like the japanese style (hori) for street fighter and the american style for Tekken.
A good pad is a cheap substitute for both and easier to carry around. Resigned myself to that for the time being.
My current weapons.
Capcom StreetFighter type games: Sega Playstation 6 button gamepad
SNK KOF / Namco Tekken/Soul Calibur type games: Sony Playstation 4 button gamepad.